Why Sponsor Oils? | source | all docs for version 0.24.0 | all versions | oilshell.org

Variable Declaration, Mutation, and Scope

This doc addresses these questions:

• How do variables behave in YSH?
• What are some practical guidelines for using them?

YSH Design Goals

YSH is a graceful upgrade to shell, and the behavior of variables follows from that philosophy.

• OSH implements shell-compatible behavior.
• YSH enhances shell with new features like expressions over typed data, which will be familiar to Python and JavaScript programmers.
• It's a stricter language.
  • Procs (shell functions) are self-contained and modular. They're understandable by reading their signature.
  • We removed dynamic scope. This mechanism isn't familiar to most programmers, and may cause accidental mutation (bugs).
  • YSH has variable declarations like JavaScript, which can prevent trivial bugs.
• Even though YSH is stricter, it should still be convenient to use interactively.

Keywords Are More Consistent and Powerful Than Builtins

YSH has 5 keywords affect shell variables. Unlike shell builtins, they're statically-parsed, and take dynamically-typed expressions on the right.

Declare With var and const

It looks like JavaScript:

var name = 'Bob'
const age = (20 + 1) * 2

echo "$name is $age years old"  # Bob is 42 years old

Note that const is enforced by a dynamic check. It's meant to be used at the top level only, not within proc or func.

const age = 'other'  # Will fail because `readonly` bit is set

Mutate With setvar and setglobal

proc p {
  var name = 'Bob'       # declare
  setvar name = 'Alice'  # mutate

  setglobal g = 42       # create or mutate a global variable
}

"Return" By Mutating a Place (advanced)

A Place is a more principled mechanism that "replaces" shell's dynamic scope. To use it:

1. Create a place with the & prefix operator
2. Pass the place around as you would any other value.
3. Assign to the place with its setValue(x) method.

Example:

proc p (s; out) {  # place is a typed param
  # mutate the place
  call out->setValue("prefix-$s")
}

var x
p ('foo', &x)  # pass a place
echo x=$x  # => x=prefix-foo

• Style guideline: In some situations, it's better to "return" a value on stdout, and use $(myproc) to retrieve it.

Comparison to Shell

Shell and bash have grown many mechanisms for "declaring" and mutating variables:

• "bare" assignments like x=foo
• builtins like declare, local, and readonly
• The -n "nameref" flag

Examples:

readonly name=World        # no spaces allowed around =
declare foo="Hello $name"
foo=$((42 + a[2]))
declare -n ref=foo         # $foo can be written through $ref

These constructs are all discouraged in YSH code.

Keywords Behave Differently at the Top Level (Like JavaScript)

The "top-level" of the interpreter is used in two situations:

1. When using YSH interactively.
2. As the global scope of a batch program.

Experienced YSH users may notice that var and setvar behave differently in the top-level scope vs. proc scope. This is caused by the tension between the interactive shell and the strictness of YSH.

In particular, the source builtin is dynamic, so YSH can't know all the names defined at the top level.

For reference, JavaScript's modern let keyword has similar behavior.

Usage Guidelines

Before going into detail on keyword behavior, here are some practical guidelines:

• Interactive sessions: Use shell's x=y, or YSH setvar. You can think of setvar like Python's assignment operator: it creates or mutates a variable.
  • Short scripts (~20 lines) can also use this style.
• Long programs: Refactor them into composable "functions", i.e. proc.
  • First wrap the whole program into proc main { }.
  • The top level should only have const declarations. (You can use var, but it has special rules, explained below.)
  • The body of proc and func should have variables declared with var.
  • Inside these code blocks, use setvar to mutate local variables, and setglobal to mutate globals.

That's all you need to remember. The following sections explain the rationale for these guidelines.

The Top-Level Scope Has Only Dynamic Checks

The lack of static checks affects the recommended usage for both interactive sessions and batch scripts.

Interactive Use: setvar only

As mentioned, you only need the setvar keyword in an interactive shell:

ysh$ setvar x = 42   # create variable 'x'
ysh$ setvar x = 43   # mutate it

Details on top-level behavior:

• var behaves like setvar: It creates or mutates a variable. In other words, a var definition can be redefined at the top-level.
• A const can also redefine a var.
• A var can't redefine a const because there's a dynamic check that disallows mutation (like shell's readonly).

Batch Use: const only

It's simpler to use only constants at the top level.

const USER = 'bob'
const HOST = 'example.com'

proc p {
  ssh $USER@$HOST ls -l
}

This is so you don't have to worry about a var being redefined by a statement like source mylib.sh. A const can't be redefined because it can't be mutated.

It may be useful to put mutable globals in a constant dictionary, as it will prevent them from being redefined:

const G = { mystate = 0 }

proc p {
  setglobal G.mystate = 1
}

proc and func Scope Have Static Checks

These YSH code units have additional static checks (parse errors):

• Every variable must be declared once and only once with var. A duplicate declaration is a parse error.
• setvar of an undeclared variable is a parse error.

Procs Don't Use "Dynamic Scope"

Procs are designed to be encapsulated and composable like processes. But the dynamic scope rule that Bourne shell functions use breaks encapsulation.

Dynamic scope means that a function can read and mutate the locals of its caller, its caller's caller, and so forth. Example:

g() {
  echo "f_var is $f_var"  # g can see f's local variables
}

f() {
  local f_var=42 g
}

f

YSH code should use proc instead. Inside a proc call, the dynamic_scope option is implicitly disabled (equivalent to shopt --unset dynamic_scope).

Reading Variables

This means that adding the proc keyword to the definition of g changes its behavior:

proc g() {
  echo "f_var is $f_var"  # Undefined!
}

This affects all kinds of variable references:

proc p {
  echo $foo         # look up foo in command mode
  var y = foo + 42  # look up foo in expression mode
}

As in Python and JavaScript, a local foo can shadow a global foo. Using CAPS for globals is a common style that avoids confusion. Remember that globals should usually be constants in YSH.

Shell Language Constructs That Write Variables

In shell, these language constructs assign to variables using dynamic scope. In YSH, they only mutate the local scope:

• x=val
  • And variants x+=val, a[i]=val, a[i]+=val
• export x=val and readonly x=val
• ${x=default}
• mycmd {x}>out (stores a file descriptor in $x)
• (( x = 42 + y ))

Builtins That Write Variables

These builtins are also "isolated" inside procs, using local scope:

• read ($REPLY)
• readarray aka mapfile
• getopts ($OPTIND, $OPTARG, etc.)
• printf -v
• unset

YSH Builtins:

• compadjust
• try and _error

Reminder: Proc Scope is Flat

All local variables in shell functions and procs live in the same scope. This includes variables declared in conditional blocks (if and case) and loops (for and while).

proc p {  
  for i in 1 2 3 {
    echo $i
  }
  echo $i  # i is still 3
}

This includes first-class YSH blocks:

proc p {
  var x = 42
  cd /tmp {
    var x = 0  # ERROR: x is already declared
  }
}

More Details

Examples of Place Mutation

The expression to the left of = is called a place. These are basically Python or JavaScript expressions, except that you add the setvar or setglobal keyword.

setvar x[1] = 2                 # array element
setvar d['key'] = 3             # dict element
setvar d.key = 3                # syntactic sugar for the above
setvar x, y = y, x              # swap

Bare Assignment

Hay allows const declarations without the keyword:

hay define Package

Package cpython {
  version = '3.12'  # like const version = ...
}

Temp Bindings

Temp bindings precede a simple command:

PYTHONPATH=. mycmd

They create a new namespace on the stack where each cell has the export flag set (declare -x).

In YSH, the lack of dynamic scope means that they can't be read inside a proc. So they're only useful for setting environment variables, and can be replaced with:

env PYTHONPATH=. mycmd
env PYTHONPATH=. $0 myproc  # using the ARGV dispatch pattern

Appendix A: More on Shell vs. YSH

This section may help experienced shell users understand YSH.

Shell:

g=G                         # global variable
readonly c=C                # global constant

myfunc() {
  local x=X                 # local variable
  readonly y=Y              # local constant

  x=mutated                 # mutate local
  g=mutated                 # mutate global
  newglobal=G               # create new global

  caller_var=mutated        # dynamic scope (YSH doesn't have this)
}

YSH:

var g = 'G'                 # global variable (discouraged)
const c = 'C'               # global constant

proc myproc {
  var x = 'L'               # local variable

  setvar x = 'mutated'      # mutate local
  setglobal g = 'mutated'   # mutate global
  setglobal newglobal = 'G' # create new global
}

Appendix B: Problems With Top-Level Scope In Other Languages

• Julia 1.5 (August 2020): The return of "soft scope" in the REPL.
  • In contrast to Julia, YSH behaves the same in batch mode vs. interactive mode, and doesn't print warnings. However, it behaves differently at the top level. For this reason, we recommend using only setvar in interactive shells, and only const in the global scope of programs.
• Racket: The Top Level is Hopeless
  • From A Principled Approach to REPL Interpreters (Onward 2020). Thanks to Michael Greenberg (of Smoosh) for this reference.
  • The behavior of var at the top level was partly inspired by this paper. It's consistent with bash's declare, and similar to JavaScript's let.

Related Documents

• Interpreter State
  • The shell has a stack of namespaces.
  • Each namespace contains {variable name -> cell} bindings.
  • Cells have a tagged value (string, array, etc.) and 3 flags (readonly, export, nameref).
• Guide to Procs and Funcs